FMEA- Failure Mode and Effect Analysis

  • FMEA has been used as a risk identification & mitigation tools for many decades.

  • Developed by US Military in 1940's.

  • Used for almost 70 years with relatively small evolutionary enhancement.

  • In 2019, substantial changes were introduced as AIAG & VDA "Harmonized" their difference for conducting FMEA.

FMEA (Failure Mode & Effect Analysis) is a structured tool to

  • Identify failure modes for process

  • Estimate its effect & risk associated with it.

  • Identify & prioritize probable cause of failure

  • Prioritize the failures modes based on the action priority.

  • Evaluate & develop control plan to contain the risk

What is FMEA?

History

  • System FMEA

  • Design FMEA

  • Machinery FMEA

  • Process FMEA

  • Reverse FMEA

Types

  1. INTENT: What is or isn't included in the scope of this project & why is the FMEA being undertaken?

  2. TIMING: When will be the FMEA done? (Includes when in the product/process development cycle to conduct the study with deadline for FMEA.

  3. TEAM: who will be the core team & extended team with roles & responsibilities?

  4. TASK: What work to be done by team?

  5. TOOLS: What are the tools required by team to complete the project?

  • New 7 step Approach (PS 2F RO R)

  • Revised Severity, Occurrence & detection Rating

  • Risk Priority Number (RPN) replaced by Action Priority (AP)

  • New FMEA sheet with color & linkage

  • PFD is a integral part

  • Use of 5T & 4M approach

  • Recommendation Actions replaced by Prevention & Detection Action

  • Added status of action

  • Added special characteristic to replace classification.

Key changes in VDA-FMEA

5T

  • Project Identification

  • Project Planning

  • Boundary Analysis

1- Planning & Preparation

  • Process Flow Diagram

  • High level process

  • Breakdown sub-process to single operation

3- Functional Analysis

  • Identify failure modes

  • Determine failure effect

  • Analyze failure cause

4- Failure Analysis

  • Risk assessment

  • Prevention & Detection Control

  • SOD Rating & AP Calculation

5- Risk Analysis

  • Sort Risk

  • Make risk mitigation action plan

  • Assign responsibility & due date

6- Optimization

  • Update FMEA Results

  • Action Plans

  • Approve & Release FMEA

7- Result Documentation

7 Step Approach

2- Structural Analysis